Movable Walls Revisited
The decade of the '90s has become one of the most volatile business decades
in recent memory. Companies who are forced to compete in the global marketplace
are quickly learning that survival dictates restructuring, downsizing or
"rightsizing." Those facilities that are adaptable to this changing business
environment work with the facility manager in accommodating this change.
Decades ago, the introduction of suspended ceiling systems was welcomed as a
great step forward. In place of standard fixed construction, the suspended
ceiling allowed the facility manager complete access and flexibility for repair
work, or for the addition of electrical, communication, data and HVAC lines.
Years later, attention was focused on providing the same level of access and
flexibility at the floor line, and raised floor systems were developed to
satisfy this requirement.
But what about the facility managers need for access and flexibility in his
vertical wall requirements? It makes a great deal of sense to provide a systems
approach to vertical walls, enveloping the office environment with access and
flexibility in all three planes.
A variety of wall "systems" have been developed over the years to accommodate
these needs, each with unique benefits designed to meet specific interior wall
requirements. Movable, demountable, operable, retractable, portable and systems
walls are all terms of similar, yet uniquely different solutions to meet this
challenge.
As a guide for building owners, facility managers and architects, the various
types of systems can be grouped and defined as follows:
Operable walls, also known as retractable walls, are
usually the most expensive type of systems because of the support mechanism
required to suspend the panels. Operable walls are generally individual panels
hung from an overhead support with rollers. The panels are simply rolled into an
open or closed position, either by hand or via a power-operated mechanism in the
overhead track. Panels may be hung individually, as pairs, or as a group. This
type of wall system requires structural support, so it cannot be moved from its
original installed position. Panel surfaces vary from steel with a baked enamel
finish to fabric covered tackable surfaces and Formicar type laminate surfaces.
Because of the complexity of the system, and the need for overhead support,
prices for a typical operable wall are in the $20 to $45+ per square foot range.
Operable walls are commonly used in areas that need to be divided instantly, by
the building occupants. Excellent for use in hotel meeting rooms, gymnasiums,
restaurants and classrooms, it's not unusual for an operable wall to extend to
ceiling heights of 30 to 35 feet and higher. Sound Transmission Classification
ratings are typically in the 38 to 52+ range. Operable walls are usually not
fire-rated, and do not have power carrying capabilities.
Portable walls are also in the upper price range of the various
wall systems, with typical prices in the $100 to $150 per lineal foot range,
installed. Portable walls are individual panel units complete with a
self-contained head and base. Panels are held in place by pressure, can be
carried to a new position and installed very quickly. Most types require ceiling
strengthening because of the upward pressure of the ceiling channel. Portable
walls are commonly used in areas which need to be divided often, but in
different layouts. These systems are popular in restaurants, hotel meeting rooms
and in schools to subdivide classrooms. STC performance is typically limited,
but since the system is used more as a divider than a permanent wall, sound
control is not a major concern. Typically not available fire-rated, and these
types of systems do not have power carrying capabilities.
Movable walls are unitized panel assemblies connected at the
joints with small panel connectors (also called "post caps"), or narrow reveals
that may be slotted to accept hang-on furniture. The base and ceiling runners
and trims are installed separately, and run continuously; panels are moved as
assembled units. Typically the panel units and connectors are provided in a
factory baked enamel finish. Movable walls are used to displace conventional
fixed walls in all types of layouts. The systems are completely engineered
including several types of door units and glazed assemblies. Because of the
modularity of the system, door and glazed units are typically interchangeable
with solid panel units. Since the panels are moved as assembled units, these
types of systems move very quickly and are ideal for locations that require
weekend or over-a-vacation changes. Movable walls generally have respectable STC
performance, in the 39-43 range. Because of their factory painted finish, they
provide a great deal of abuse resistance. Accessibility into the wall cavity
varies by manufacturer. Some provide excellent accessibility, others have
virtually no access except at the cavity between adjoining units.
Electrification is normally handled at the joint cavity, and may require special
"slim-line" electrical boxes depending on the thickness of the system. Unitized
assemblies typically do not allow for split finishes -- panels have to be the
same on both sides of the unit. However, a wide variety of panel colors and
finishes are generally available. Depending upon the finish selected, movable
walls are in the $100 to $125 per lineal foot price range, installed.
Demountable steel walls consist of metal-faced gypsum panels
that are suspended from a separate stud and track framework. Ceiling runners,
floor tracks and studs are installed similar to standard drywall construction.
The systems are moved by disassembling and removing individual panels, trims,
studs and tracks. Normally finished in baked enamel, some of the systems offer a
wide variety of specialty finishes, including powder-paint for hospital and
cleanroom applications, vinyl-clad steel for a less institutional appearance,
and chalkboard or markerboard surfaces for classroom applications. Demountable
steel walls do not move as quickly as movable wall systems, but are less
expensive and can provide better performance. Most often this type of system is
used to replace standard drywall in offices, schools and hospitals. Prices
generally range from $80 to $100 per lineal foot, installed, for the basic
system with upcharges for specialty finishes. Because the panels are installed
individually on each side, greater design flexibility can be achieved. STC
performance in usually excellent; some can exceed 50. Many of these systems can
provide fire ratings in the one and two hour range. The steel-faced gypsum panel
provides excellent impact resistance and structural stability.
Demountable gypsum walls consist of vinyl-covered gypsum board
that snaps, clips, screws or is suspended from a stud and track framework.
Similar to demountable steel walls, the ceiling and floor tracks run
continuously, studs extend from floor to ceiling. The systems are moved by
disassembling and removing individual panels, trims, studs and track. Depending
upon the method of panel attachment, some systems are "progressive," meaning
panels are installed sequentially and cannot be individually removed. Other
systems are "non-progressive," meaning each individual panel is point accessible
without disturbing panels adjacent to it. Some systems will accept both
vinyl-clad gypsum and steel-clad gypsum, offering the facility manager and the
design team a great deal of flexibility. Priced in the $30 to $60 per lineal
foot range, installed, demountable gypsum systems are the most economical of all
the systems and compete head-to-head with standard construction. The systems are
used in a wide variety of applications including schools, offices, hospitals and
lease-tenant space. STC performance is comparable to standard drywall (36 STC),
but performance can be enhanced by installing sound absorption batts in the wall
cavity. STC ranges from 35 to 50+, depending on the system
configuration. Whatever type of system is selected, walls that
are movable offer many benefits to the end-user:
Speed of installation - Most systems can be installed much
faster than standard drywall construction since the mudding, taping, sanding,
priming and painting are eliminated.
Return on investment - Many of the systems are considered "office
furniture" by the IRS and can be depreciated in a fraction of the time of
standard construction.
Privacy - As indicated above, STC ratings up to 50 are possible.
Environmental impact - Through the use of movable systems, a great
deal of the waste generated in office reconfiguration is eliminated. Good for
the environment, and an added cost savings to the building owner.
Cost savings - The end-user realizes a substantial cost savings each
time he takes down and reuses the system.
|
 |